Fire and Water

Over the weekend, I finally had some time to listen to an unusual tape cassette. Actually, I should rewind here because I needed to buy a tape cassette player in order to listen to it. Luckily, given my advanced age, I was familiar with cassette tapes and recorders and their various functions. I was an aficionado back in the day for recording popular songs off the radio.

Anyway, the tape was recorded on July 11th, 2000. It was a professional astrology reading. My husband, Dennis, was active in Rotary International at that time and they had just held a fund-raiser, which included a silent auction. The piece of paper stated “An Hour-Long Astrological Consultation with Carol Banner”. As I walked around the tables and looked at fabulous opportunities and gift ideas, I kept returning to Ms. Banner. Finally, I raised the bid to $75.00 and walked into the dining room for dinner.

Yes, I was the winner. I was excited. I’ve always had an interest in astrology and faithfully followed my daily “Cancer” sign horoscope in the newspaper’s entertainment section. The only aspect I knew back then was that as a Cancer crab, I literally carried my home on my back, and that home and the people in it were everything to me. I also knew that Cancer was a water sign; and water always draws me towards it.

It took about three months to schedule the consultation. Ms. Banner had an office right in her home. She had asked for my information in advance (birth date, time of birth, place of birth etc.) but when I arrived, she asked for this information for most of my family members too; including my mother. Hmm.

What I didn’t realize was that she was going to record the session. I loved that idea, so I could replay it at any time to refresh my memory. That I have held onto it for 24 years speaks of its importance to me. And this is quite ironic, as one thing I learned that day about Cancerians is that we love to hold on to things and we love keeping records about the past!

The twist, however, is that I may have kept it, but never meaningfully referred to it again.

Until now. Honestly, I thought I had lost it when we moved nine years ago, but I just found it in a large plastic storage box. And some of its insights are revealing.

Here’s how she started:

“You’re more than just a Cancer, you are water-personified.”

Apparently, I have the sun in the Cancer water sign; the moon is in a water sign (Pisces), and Scorpio is the only other water sign, and it holds Neptune. No wonder I have dreams with large waves in them.

“In astrology,” she continued, “there are four elements: air, water, fire, earth. They are really just psychological functions. The water function is a feeling function. Earth is practical. Fire is intuition and enthusiasm. Air is a rational, thinking, objective type. Notice here in your chart, we have zero air.”

She was right. All three spaces on the chart dedicated to air signs (Gemini, Aquarius and Libra) were blank; no planets in them.

“It doesn’t mean you don’t have a brain,” she explained. “It just means that your thinking is done emotionally.”

I was comfortable with that assessment and can easily apply it to my life. I realize, for example, that when I look at a painting, I’m not concentrating on its structure or analyzing its intent, I’m interested in how it makes me feel. Does it bring me joy or a sense of foreboding? I’ll be honest. Sometimes, it brings plain boredom. I feel nothing. The same applies to music. I’ve always enjoyed rock and popular music over, say, classical music. Those music genres just reach me. In fact, songwriters write Top 40 hits specifically with hooks in them to make you feel something, to react to it. I am very susceptible to that.

But the next comment she said irritated me.

“Your moon is in Pisces. This gives you an addictive trait, but it doesn’t have to be alcohol.”

“You can be just as addicted to chocolate bars or buying books, for example, which I don’t think is going to happen with no air signs,” she added, while laughing.

I didn’t pick up on that then, but I certainly took offense when I heard it a few days ago.  

I thought it was rude as it was utterly incorrect as well. Shortly after, she revised her thinking.

“With no air, they (Cancers) either avoid intellectualism or are trying to improve, learn. They are trying to add to their knowledge to compensate.”

Bingo. Learning is a driving force within me. I took a part-time job as a reporter years ago, to place myself in situations where I would learn and use my passion for writing at the same time. There is a need for me to know what is happening in the world and I watch a healthy amount of news and feature stories to fill that need. And I’ve been a voracious reader since I was a child. I’m glad she chose to frame the chart differently.

And then we moved onto my mother. I referenced struggling with my mom, but that it was nothing new.

“Well, number one,” Carol replied, “she wants to be the center of attention. What she needs more than anything and the worst thing you could do to her is ignore her. And she’s got a lot of criticisms that she doesn’t keep to herself.”

“Your mother has an Aquarian Moon. Aquarian moons will never understand a Pisces moon (me). She will say something she thinks is instructional, and you’ll be weeping in the corner.” (Carol wasn’t wrong, but I laughed in that moment.)

“She’s a fire sign.” Carol said. “She truly cannot help herself. It’s like going to the zoo and telling the elephant to be a flamingo. It’s not happening. So, trying to get mom to be sensitive…” she trails off and doesn’t finish.

“Where you have all this water and lack of air, she’s got a lot of air and lack of water. She really doesn’t understand all the emotionality. She just DOESN’T,” she emphasized.

A memory flashed for me. My son Will had just graduated from college and we were out to dinner. Each person at the table had something to say in his honor. When I spoke, I choked up and cried. I couldn’t help it. And mom looked at me with such an expression of disdain; she was just shy of smirking.

“Isn’t this a little bit over the top?” she said through her gaze towards me. And once again, I was looking at a strength of being able to feel in the moment and emote public pride in my son and I was suddenly converting it into a weakness. This was the effect she could have on me; even if I fought it.

I’ve looked at our relationship through the lens of her relationship with her own mother; seeing almost DNA patterns of ingrained emotional distance. Walls. I’ve examined it as a single generational story of a woman who lost her husband at age 47 and had two dutiful daughters who helped her and always tried to do right by her, even when she took many liberties with that. She always seemed to want to control us well into our 50s. (Truthfully, it’s not that it worked, but there was some influence there.)

And now I’ve arrived at our astrological signs. In my eyes, the summation is that everything played a role to create a difficult dynamic. There was always love, but there was not enough of a healthy exposure to it.

Carol had mentioned that “you and your mom have been placed together to hang out; to understand the difference in natures.” I argue that if the universe placed us together, it should not have been a mother-daughter relationship. We should have been peers, or maybe sisters. The power was too one-sided.

She has now been gone 20 months; not quite two years. I thought the aftereffects would bring pain as we grieved; but then we would feel freer and move forward eventually. Period. And It’s not like that didn’t happen, but there has been a growing parallel feeling of becoming more myself.

She is not as present in my head anymore. Time has allowed her influence to fade. I don’t have to consider her opinion or receive any disapproving gazes from her anymore. I don’t need to seek approval.

And the result is my thinking, and conclusions on those thoughts and ideas are cleaner; stronger. I’m canceling out old habits I’m tired of and feeling a certain energy I can use as I see fit. It’s available.

I didn’t see this coming. It’s not that I’m a new person, I just have a clearer view of who I am supposed to be. I FEEL it.

Photo by Gabriela Hughes on Pexels.com

13 responses to “Fire and Water”

  1. I appreciate how this story weaves together nostalgic bits, mother-daughter conflict, and a growing self-awareness, Melanie. You must be aware that your stories often lead to some sort of personal transformation, a key element of memoir.  :-D

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you Marian. ♥ This one wrote itself. I had a lighter/humorous tone planned and it wound its way somewhere else. :) Now, you have me thinking about all the memoirs I’ve read where we see a personal transformation. You clearly experienced one leaving the stricter form of your faith and feeling freer to be the true Marian in red shoes! And Jeanette Walls definitely had one leaving the life of poverty behind. There is a thread of breaking through to a better life in these (and more.) Anyway, thanks for giving me something to think about.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. petespringerauthor Avatar
    petespringerauthor

    I’m a bit of a skeptic when it comes to astrology, even though I try to keep an open mind. I’m sure there’s a lot of things I don’t know about the mystical world. I related to your quality of wanting to learn because I have a lot of that in me too. (I’m a Sagittarian.) It’s cool to look back at your reading years later to see how accurate it was.

    When my wife and I first got together, my future mother-in-law did graphoanalysis. She did a reading on me by studying my handwriting. What she said about me through my writing rang true for the most part.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think that’s cool about using graphoanalysis to “read” who you are, Pete! You absolutely have an open mind, and there was truth in it! As I look at it, I’m not surprised that a strong desire to learn is part of you too. First, you were literally teaching others how to learn and you’re a writer which requires research. Your dad modeled research and learning everyday. I’m sure you learned a ton from him. I’ll admit I was pretty amazed at how accurate Carol was, and frankly, it was helpful to see this piece of why my mom was the way she was.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I really enjoyed this piece Melanie. I’ve always been open to astrology but never really delved deeper than seeing what traits my sign (Virgo) include. Your reading did delve deeper and I find it very interesting what you were told – especially the “addictive” trait. We automatically think negatively about this word bcz it usually relates to drugs and alcohol. You definitely are addicted to research and learning new things about your world! I both applaud and envy that. What the astrologer told you about your Mom and your relationship was mind blowing and nothing short of what a therapist would say as well. I’m glad you’re finding peace with your relationship with your Mom and the effects it has had on your life. My daughter and I share the same birthday and same astrology sign. It explains A LOT of our relationship 😄!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. It’s funny you should mention the word “therapist.” At one point in the reading she stated that she often feels like one for people. And I wrote (before I removed it) that it felt like therapy for me. At times, it was uncomfortable. Anyway, It was nothing short of fascinating. The mom issues WERE mind-blowing. Truly. Also, being “water-personified” explains a lot about my need for being out on the water hahaha! It is interesting about you and your daughter, but sharing the same day works for you as you are very close. It might be fun someday to get a reading yourself. She knew stuff that blew me away. Thanks Pam! :)

      Like

  4. I really enjoyed the post. Oftentimes, mother-daughter relationships are difficult to navigate and many women feel like they still need their mother’s approval which they could never get when they were younger.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Pooja! That’s a good point. A daughter can be ten or thirty or fifty, and if she’s never had her mom’s approval, she needs that resolved. She’ll keep returning to the “well” hoping “this time” will be different. What a tangled web we weave! 😊 Thanks so much for your visit here.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. My pleasure and I think so too. I think daughters that didn’t get their mother’s approval hope that if they change and try to be perfect their mother will notice but that rarely happens if ever.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. I love that you waited all this time to listen to the tape, and how much more meaningful it is now than then.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks Jacqui! Deep down, I don’t think I was ready to “confront” the information about my mom. 24 years later, I KNOW so much more and am at peace with the “whys”. Plus, it was fun to hear about what my son’s future might be. Now that it’s here, she was eerily correct. Thanks for visiting and have a nice weekend.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. That tape cassette player detail really threw me back haha. Finding that old recording and hearing all that stuff about your water signs and lack of air is fascinating. Kinda makes you wonder if it all applies, right? Like, the emotional thinking and being drawn to music that makes you feel something. The part about your mom is interesting too. It sounds like you’ve been doing a lot of reflecting on your relationship with her, both through your experiences and now with this astrology lens.

    Thanks for sharing this story!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Hi Ritish, thanks for your comment. It was more than eerie to hear the astrologer’s words and know that they are (for the most part) true. It’s a crazy concept that we are who we are because of where the planets were positioned in the sky at the time of our birth. And yet, I cannot deny how I process my world. And I have been trying to unravel the “whys” of my relationship with my mom for years. My sister is right there with me. It was somewhat comforting to learn that her emotional distance was “written in the stars.” It explains a piece of it, anyway, Thanks for the follow Ritish!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Pooja G Cancel reply