Opening Up Caskets and Conversations

โ€”

,

My thoughts for this post started last week as I read the latest post from Marian Beaman titled โ€œLittle Girl and a Coffin in the House.โ€ She recounts the experience she had in the 1940s when her grandfather died and the showing was inside his home. She saw him in his coffin. In fact, she sat quietly in the same room with him while others paid their respects. She was five. It was an interesting story about Marian and the times and practices surrounding death. Here’s a link:

https://marianbeaman.com/2025/09/17/little-girl-coffin-house/

I noticed that many of the comments that the readers left were โ€œI never saw a dead bodyโ€ or โ€œI saw one only once,โ€ etc. This is what they drew from it.

I thought about it, too. When my dad died, it was only a memorial service; there was no viewing. There wasnโ€™t one for my grandfather, Billie, either. I was alright with that; I didnโ€™t want to see them lifeless. In fact, I really didnโ€™t want to see anyone lifeless; ever. It made me uncomfortable.

Fast forward to 1986 and I was dating Dennis. He was in banking, and the wife of one of his customers had passed away. He wanted to go to the viewing at the funeral home.

โ€œDo you mind if I stay away from the casket?โ€ I asked.

โ€œNo, of course not,โ€ he replied, and I sighed with relief.

We arrived and mingled with other people coming to pay their respects. I knew Dennis would make his way towards the casket at some point, but he was still chatting. The plan was for me to hang back by the heavy draperies; maybe look distracted.

Suddenly, the widower, Walt, came out of nowhere and exclaimed, โ€œDennis! Iโ€™m so happy you came to this, thank you!โ€

Dennis smiled and introduced me.

โ€œNice to meet you, Melanie,โ€ and then he suddenly put his arms around Dennis and me both, and said, โ€œLetโ€™s go see Joanie!โ€ and pulled us towards the front of the room.

I looked at Dennis with pleading eyes. He understood, but what could he do?

Up we walked, right up to the left side of the casket, where Walt stopped, and said, โ€œDoesnโ€™t she look lovely?โ€

We were standing near her face. I had been trying to look ANYWHERE but there, but I couldnโ€™t delay it any longer.

I glanced at her. I had never met Joanie, so I wasnโ€™t sure if she was looking good or not. There was makeup, but in all honesty, I saw a certain waxiness too. I think I was a little shocked at it all.

But what I really saw was how Walt was looking at her. Clearly, he had loved her. He wanted to share her with friends and family one last time; strangers, too.

It was then that I agreed wholeheartedly that she looked wonderful, and thatโ€™s all Walt needed. He was in mourning. He did not know about my hesitancy towards seeing the dead.

I definitely didnโ€™t see my mother. In fact, she probably had the most unique memorial of all. At her request, it was on a boat, about three miles off of Miami. There was no casket as she had been cremated, and we scattered her remains over the Neptune Memorial Reef.

This is an artificial reef owned by Dignity Memorial. Those who choose cremation opt for their remains to be deployed to the Reef  โ€” by literally becoming a part of it. Families can also choose to scatter ashes over the reef, like we selected. Dignity then creates a memorial plaque, which they place underwater on the site with the loved oneโ€™s name and inscription.

Leaving a trail of sunflowers for mom; her favorite flower.

Death isnโ€™t easy on the living. Seeing it up close is well, startling. Many people donโ€™t want to talk about it either.

Perhaps we can learn something from the Bhutanese people, who apparently contemplate death five times daily because such regular reflection can lead to a happier, more fulfilled life by โ€œfostering gratitude and making one appreciate the present moment.โ€ Itโ€™s an interesting philosophy to โ€œnormalizeโ€ death; to make us less afraid to see dead people and to talk openly about it.

So, Iโ€™m opening it up. Donโ€™t be alarmed. Iโ€™ve just thought about my own death and final wishes. Momโ€™s resting place is perfect for her, but I think I want something on land. Right now, I vacillate between burial and cremation. I do like the idea of being outside, somewhere near trees; their leaves dropping nearby in the fall months while visitors come to see family or do grave rubbings.

If they walk my way, they may see an inscription on the gravestone from the first movie I ever saw in the theater: The Sound of Music. I’ve always carried those songs and lyrics with me. I was only five, at the beginning my life. It would be simple.

โ€œShe must have done someโ€ฆthing good.โ€

I can hear those musical notes now, and even Christopher Plummerโ€™s chuckle in the middle. I would love for people to walk away humming a song.

But no worries, please. I also know that “I have miles to go before I sleep.” (Robert Frost)

Photo by Maria Orlova on Pexels.com

27 responses to “Opening Up Caskets and Conversations”

  1. It’s no surprise that I loved everything about your post, Melanie, because you always delve into interesting topics. First off, I love the simple but meaningful inscription of, โ€œShe must have done someโ€ฆthing good.โ€ I have often shared the words of my principal and friend, Nancy, which evoke a similar thought. “The greatest gift is the gift of yourself.”

    My father-in-law was a hard-working man (like 12 hours a day) who owned a second-generation trucking business with his two brothers. He lived a simple life. His only hobby was golf. (My wife told me he once had a hole-in-one and a 300 game in bowling.) As a golfing hack, I dreaded that he would invite me for a round when I was engaged to Debbie and think, ‘Who is this wimp my daughter is about to marry?’ ๐Ÿคฃ

    He divorced my mother-in-law later in life, and his two daughters and one son decided on cremation following his death. Following his celebration of life, the kids got the idea to sneak onto his favorite golf course around midnight to scatter his ashes. (Illegal, I’m sure, but one of those things that still felt right.) There we went, flashlights in tow.

    My final thought is the importance of people planning their deaths. That sounds morbid, but it’s also responsible so that children don’t have to guess and feel guilty wondering if they’re making the right choices during a vulnerable time. My parents had all their wishes spelled out. They wanted a funeral mass, to be buried in the graveyard side-by-side in the cemetery next to their church, etc. It made things so much easier for us, not having to guess. My dad had already written his own obituary, and my mom had written a rough draft of hers.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I couldn’t agree more with planning ahead, so children don’t have to guess, Pete. Writing the obituaries is even smarter! I love that. I’ll admit that I don’t have service details worked out; it’s like I’m giving myself my own reminder to do it! ๐Ÿ˜‚ I also love, love sneaking onto the golf course, that’s awesome. Marian was really the inspiration for this one, but thank you for your wonderful words! They mean a lot. I love that you connect my words to Nancy. I know she was such a close friend. Thank you!!!!!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, I had read Marian’s post earlier. Even as an adult, I’m uncomfortable going to an open casket ceremony, but as you said, these rituals are for the living. Oh, I could feel how awkward that must have been for you. People grieve in their own ways, so I won’t find fault with the husband, but I can’t imagine encouraging people to come look at a loved one’s body.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Right, I would never fault him either, but I was surprised! It left a lasting impression on me. Maybe it was a lesson and I didn’t even know it. Everything tends to happen for a reason, I guess. Thanks for the follow-up, Pete. ๐Ÿ˜Š

        Liked by 1 person

  2. We don’t like to talk about death do we. I always joke with my wife and kids that I don’t want a funeral. I want a wake where people relax, listen to music, and think of the memories we shared. My kids laugh at me, but I’m serious. If there have to be tears, I want tears of happiness and joy, not sadness. As far as the Sound of Music, love it. Ha, ha. Great points Melanie.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I used to work at Legacy.com many years ago which hosts online obituary pages for newspapers around the world. We talked frequently about Celebrations of Life – just what you are requesting, Brian. I think more and more people are following that positive take on death. I love that you want tears of happiness, and listen to some great music too! (I guess I’ve come a long way from not wanting to see a dead person to working with obituaries everyday! ๐Ÿ˜Š) Thanks so much, Brian. I think you said something just the other day about how some posts are so easy and spill out, while others are work. This one spilled -I couldn’t stop typing!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, definitely sounds like youโ€™ve come a long way! Ha ha. I touch on death and obits a little in one my future gratitude blogs, but youโ€™ve got me thinking. May need to see where this goes. And good for you. So cool when the writing just spills out. A great feeling! Thanks for sharing.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh, that’s so cool! I hope you get a great piece out of following your thoughts, Brian. Thanks so much for your follow-up and well wishes with writing.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. I’ve seen my grandma, my parents, and my husband’s parents in caskets. With my parents, we went to the “family room” behind the funeral room to view them one more time before they closed the caskets, but the caskets have a window to show the face of the deceased. I was at one sister’s death bed in the hospital. She was unconscious from the congested heart failure but was on life support. The family took turns to be with her individually. I was with her talking to her and stroking her forehead. Then her face relaxed but she was bleeding through the nose. I got the nurse and the nurse said she was gone. They shut off the life support but had to wait for the momentum to fade before the doctor pronounced her death.
    My grandma had a burial and we visited her graveside twice a year growing up. My parents were cremated and shared one cubicle in the cemetery. My father-in-law was cremated but my mother-in-law wanted burial. They shared the same plot in the ground. My son-in-law’s mother was cremated and had the ashes scattered in the ocean. My sister’s ashes scattered in a garden.

    I haven’t thought about myself yet, but thank you for your post, Melanie! I’ll start thinking about that and spell out what I want to do.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wow, Miriam, what an experience to witness the moment of death of your sister. That had to have been extremely emotional. I’m sorry. Ahh, one of your family members ashes were scattered in the ocean, like my mom. People do choose different ways to be laid to rest. I like the garden choice! Oh, that’s so sweet that you got something from the post, and will start thinking. I love that. Thank you. โค๏ธ

      Like

  4. This is such a lovely post–even if it’s about a morbid topic.

    “Death isnโ€™t easy on the living” as you point out. Yes, in your story I guessed that the ebullient Dennis was going to pull you toward the casket, but the moment was probably not as dreadful as you imagined it would be.

    And, yes, I do remember your tribute to your mother and the reference to the Neptune Memorial Reef.

    Thanks for the shout-out here, Melanie. You are so very supportive as always! :-D

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for the inspiration, Marian. Really. It seems to have struck a chord for some. Although he could have, Dennis didn’t take me up, the widower brought both of us up. Yikes! ๐Ÿ˜Š And you’re right, I have discussed mom’s unique service in the past. Thanks again, I appreciate it, Marian!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I’ve got tingles all over from reading this piece, Melanie. “She must’ve done some…thing…good”. Yes, indeed. You, do, you do! Thank you for teaching me about the Bhutanese practice…contemplation. Every day. Sending love and big hugs! ๐Ÿ’๐Ÿ˜‰๐Ÿ’

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Aww, thanks, Vicki. I’m glad there were tingles. It gave me tingles, too. ๐Ÿ˜Š I wrote it very quickly, like it was perched there already. I *think* some readers appreciated the opportunity to think about and open up about this “uncomfortable” topic. Take your power and frame it in the most helpful way. Big hugs, too! ๐Ÿฅฐ๐Ÿฅฐ

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Love the insightโ€ฆit was โ€œperchedโ€ waiting for you to give it life through your words. So good! ๐Ÿฅฐ

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Thank you!!!! We writers love those moments. They, and you are the best! Love your kindness. ๐Ÿฅฐโค๏ธ

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Xo! ๐Ÿฅฐโค๏ธ๐Ÿฅฐ

        Liked by 1 person

  6. This is such an interesting conversation because I just took my kids to see my dad’s marker at the columbarium last night. They had so many questions about cremation and whether Bumpa could see them.

    Love your highlight of the Bhutanese practice of contemplating death. I can’t imagine doing it five times a day but not avoiding it seems healthy.

    The Sound of Music – seems perfect for you. You are one of my favorite things for sure! <3

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wow. Talk about timing! I am fascinated about your conversation with them. If it isn’t uncormfortable for you, you should write about it; their reactions, their thinking and your thinking! It feels right to walk the path to teach them, within reason. And oh my goodness, Wynne you are bringing tears turning the table with another song from the soundtrack! Thank you, you are incredibly generous in your sentiment. โค๏ธ

      Liked by 1 person

  7. This was such a thoughtful post, Melanie. I donโ€™t remember being at any funerals as a little girl, I know family and friends died but my folks didnโ€™t go to any funerals and never let us go to them. Iโ€™ve been to several as an adult, and Iโ€™ve seen a few dead bodies. Each time itโ€™s startling to me, so whenever I have a choice, I avoid the viewing.
    My mom and stepdad died giving us no idea what their final wishes were. My mom refused to talk about death at all, so when she passed, we had to guess about what to do.
    I have no fear of talking about my death, Iโ€™m as prepared as I can be. I just hope I did some good while I was here.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ahh, I think the story of your mom is not rare, Rose. As Brian said in an earlier comment “we don’t like talking about death, do we?” Some feel its morbid. I think that feeling exacerbates that. I’m sorry you felt like you had to guess, it doesn’t help with closure. The good news is that you clearly learned from that, and are prepared as you can be. And with your family and grandchildren and speaking out on issues you care out, you have done much good. ๐Ÿ’• (Just as a side note, I typically go to the Reader everyday for posts, but yu haven’t been on, or I’m missing them?) Let me know.)

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Interesting post Melanie. As I write in my new book (about to be launched later this week), most people are death averse and would rather not talk about. Sadly, I’ve seen my share of dead bodies. ๐Ÿงก

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Debby. Marian got me thinking on this one. Is the book you are referencing the one you have been writing about grief? xo

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes it is Melanie. Hopefully, out by end of this week!! ๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿ˜‹

        Liked by 1 person

      2. That’s good news! I’m very happy for you that publication is imminent because the book has been an emotional journey for you. Congratulations, Debby! Hugs. ๐Ÿ’œ

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Thank you very much Melanie. ๐Ÿงก

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Victoria Cancel reply